Stop Chasing Numbers: How to Coach Behaviours That Build Winning Teams

Last week’s issue: How Leaders Influence Pay Promotions

Sign Up 
Join 7500+ leaders

If you're just joining us, welcome to House of Leadership. A weekly leadership newsletter helping leaders grow their careers.

If you find value in these newsletters and would like to support this publication, you can become a paid subscriber.

Looking to start a newsletter? Use Beehiiv (it’s what we use)

Welcome back to House of Leadership. We explore what it really takes to grow and lead successfully in a fast-paced, high-performance environment. We go beyond metrics to talk about influence, visibility, mindset, and the habits that separate good from great. Whether you're climbing the ladder or helping others do the same, you'll find practical insights to elevate your impact.

👉 This week: Why (and how) to coach to behaviours over numbers.

Whether you’re:

• Leading a high-output support or product team

• Growing future leaders

• Scaling your culture beyond one office or one region

The shift from numbers-first leadership to behaviour-first leadership might be the single most impactful change you can make. Let’s unpack why most leaders get stuck chasing metrics, why that strategy falls apart long-term, and how to build a team that naturally delivers the right outcomes, without constant push or fear.

Launch Your Amazon Product to $100K+ in Revenue—Fast!

Want to quickly scale your new Amazon product launches into listings earning over $100K annually—in less than two months? Stack Influence makes it easy by automating thousands of micro-influencer collaborations each month. Say goodbye to complicated outreach, negotiating influencer fees, and managing complex campaigns. With Stack Influence, influencers are paid only in your products, creating authentic user-generated content (UGC) that drives real engagement and boosts your organic Amazon rankings.

Leading brands like Magic Spoon, Unilever, and MaryRuth Organics already rely on Stack Influence to achieve impressive sales growth, enhance brand visibility, and build genuine connections with customers. Fully automated management means effortless campaigns, giving you complete control without lifting a finger. Boost your listings, increase external traffic, and own full rights to impactful influencer-generated images and videos.

Experience rapid, stress-free growth and proven results with micro-influencer marketing.

Get 10% OFF this month!

🚧 Why numbers alone create fragile teams

Most leaders are trained to chase numbers.

• Ticket close rates

• Revenue per head

• Cost to serve

• Churn percentages

It’s tempting. Numbers are clear. You can measure them, present them, and feel accomplished when they move.

But numbers only tell you what happened, not how it happened or why. When we focus only on outcomes, we accidentally reward the wrong actions:

• Speed over quality

• Silence over healthy debate

• Shortcuts over thoroughness

• Individual wins over team health

The result? Teams that hit targets… until they burn out, quit, or produce hidden damage that explodes down the line.

🧠 Mindset shift: Build the system, not just the scoreboard

Ask yourself:

• What behaviours consistently lead to strong numbers?

• What do my best people do differently, even if it doesn’t immediately show in metrics?

• Am I building habits that will hold when I’m not watching?

The most effective leaders focus on embedding systems of behaviour, not just pushing people toward outcomes. You move from being a scorekeeper to being a coach. You focus on practice reps, not just final game stats.

⚖️ Behaviours are the foundation of sustainable excellence

A numbers-only team might sprint hard for a quarter. A behaviour-driven team can thrive year after year.

Great teams are built on daily habits like:

• Following through on commitments, even when it’s inconvenient

• Owning problems instead of blaming or deflecting

• Speaking up early when they sense risk or confusion

• Coaching each other up, not just protecting their own turf

When you coach to behaviours, you create a team that knows how to win on their own terms, and doesn’t need constant micromanagement or threats.

💬 A quick real example from my world

A support analyst on my team was consistently just above the ticket target but had poor follow-through. Customer updates were delayed, and internal documentation was minimal.

Instead of hammering him on "numbers," we focused on behaviour:

Over two quarters, his trust scores skyrocketed, peer feedback improved, and ironically… his overall close rate also went up because he was solving issues thoroughly the first time.

Make your marketing less boring

The best marketing ideas come from marketers who live it. That’s what The Marketing Millennials delivers: real insights, fresh takes, and no fluff. Written by Daniel Murray, a marketer who knows what works, this newsletter cuts through the noise so you can stop guessing and start winning. Subscribe and level up your marketing game.

Sign Up Free

🧱 Why this is so powerful for scaling leaders

When your future managers grow up in a behaviour-first culture, they learn to coach the why, not just chase the what. They:

• Build trust-based relationships

• Spot and address small problems before they become big ones

• Develop teams that are self-correcting and self-motivating

⚡ Ready to make this shift?

Numbers are still important, they’re the scoreboard. But behaviours are the daily plays, the drills, the practice that actually move the scoreboard consistently.

When you coach to behaviours, you build a culture that can’t help but succeed. You create teams that innovate, adapt, and sustain high performance without burnout or shortcuts.

🔒 Up next, in the Premium section…

I’m going to share the practical, battle-tested Behaviour-First Leadership Toolkit I’ve used with my own managers and teams. Inside, you’ll get:

• 💬 Exact talk tracks and phrases to use in 1:1s (so you avoid “good job, but…” vagueness forever)

• 🎯 A template for building your own Team Behaviour Charter that everyone actually lives by

• 🔁 Real examples of reframing underperformers from metrics obsession to behaviour mastery

• 📈 How to design incentives and recognition systems that make behaviours stick

These aren’t fluffy ideas. They’re the same tools I’ve used to transform teams from metric-chasing, reactive groups into confident, self-driving units that win big (and keep winning).

If you’ve ever wanted to feel like your team can deliver without you constantly checking dashboards, this section is for you.

👉 [Upgrade to Premium to unlock the full toolkit and start building your behaviour-first culture today »]

You’ve read the free stuff—now unlock the tools that actually move the needle. From plug-and-play talk tracks to proven leadership templates, this is the edge your peers wish they had. Upgrade now and lead with confidence, clarity, and calm—every single week.

Already a paying subscriber? Sign In.

A subscription gets you:

• • Plug-and-play talk tracks - Get word-for-word scripts for handling tough conversations, performance reviews, and escalation calls—so you never freeze or fumble.
• • Confidence boosters before key moments - Quick-read mindset resets and one-liners to ground you before team meetings, 1:1s, or presentations.
• • Proven leadership templates - Use battle-tested coaching plans, escalation frameworks, and team comms templates that save you hours and build trust fast.
• • Messaging that lands - Learn how to say what you mean with clarity and confidence—whether you’re giving tough feedback or rallying a demotivated team.
• • Creative engagement ideas - Inject energy into your team with easy-to-steal ideas for engagement, recognition, and alignment—even when morale is low.