How Leaders Influence Pay, Promotions & Offers (Without Sounding Pushy)

Last week’s issue: Feedback that Lands, without burning bridges

Sign Up 
Join 7500+ leaders

If you're just joining us, welcome to House of Leadership. A weekly leadership newsletter helping leaders grow their careers.

If you find value in these newsletters and would like to support this publication, you can become a paid subscriber.

Looking to start a newsletter? Use Beehiiv (it’s what we use)

Welcome back to House of Leadership. We explore what it really takes to grow and lead successfully in a fast-paced, high-performance environment. We go beyond metrics to talk about influence, visibility, mindset, and the habits that separate good from great. Whether you're climbing the ladder or helping others do the same, you'll find practical insights to elevate your impact.

👉 This week: Negotiating what you’re worth.

Whether it’s:

• Asking for a promotion you’ve earned

• Making the case for a pay increase

• Negotiating your joining package when starting a new role

The ability to influence up is what separates average performers from rising execs. Because at some point, doing a great job isn’t enough, you also have to advocate for yourself.

Let’s unpack why it matters, what gets in the way, and how to do it well.

Keep more of what you earn

Collective is the first all-in-one financial solution exclusively for solopreneurs. Members save an average of $10,000 a year by optimizing their taxes via an S Corp.*

Membership includes:

• LLC and S Corp formation

• Payroll

• Monthly bookkeeping

• Quarterly tax estimates

• Annual business tax filing

• Access to a team of experts

Enjoy peace of mind while maximizing your profits, and enjoy extra time to focus on growing your business.

Use code SPRINGFREE at checkout and get your first month free!

Get started

_{*Based on the average 2022 tax savings of active Collective users with an S Corp tax election for the 2022 tax year}

🚧 Why Smart Leaders End Up Underselling Themselves

High performers often tell themselves:

Unfortunately, that’s not how it works. (trust me, I’ve done this myself)

Promotion decisions, raises, and comp bands are influenced by:

• Visibility

• Framing

• Strategic self-advocacy

The truth? If you don’t ask, you don’t get. But if you ask poorly, you risk sounding entitled or unaware of the bigger picture.

🧠 Mindset Shift: Think Like a Peer, Not a Pleader

Before the strategy, let’s fix the mindset.

Instead of:

Try:

Leaders respect logic, clarity, and confidence, not emotion or comparison.

Learn AI in 5 minutes a day

What’s the secret to staying ahead of the curve in the world of AI? Information. Luckily, you can join 1,000,000+ early adopters reading The Rundown AI — the free newsletter that makes you smarter on AI with just a 5-minute read per day.

Sign up to start learning.

⚖️ What You’re Really Negotiating

You're not just asking for more money or a new title. You’re asking for:

• Recognition of scope

• Investment in retention

• A long-term partnership

Your job is to connect the dots between:
✅ Your impact
✅ The company’s priorities
✅ What’s fair and market-aligned

🧱 Up next, in the Premium section…

I’ll walk you through specific, high-impact talk tracks for:

• 💸 Negotiating a raise during performance reviews

• 📈 Making a strategic case for promotion

• 💼 Securing stronger terms when joining a new company

• 🎯 Handling “we don’t have budget” objections

• 🧭 Framing your asks with confidence (and not desperation)

These are proven scripts used by real leaders (including me) to secure career-defining opportunities, without burning bridges.

🔒 Premium Section: The Talk Tracks That Win Influence

👉 Upgrade to Premium to unlock the full negotiation toolkit »

Let’s make sure your next big conversation ends with:

Not:

You’ve read the free stuff—now unlock the tools that actually move the needle. From plug-and-play talk tracks to proven leadership templates, this is the edge your peers wish they had. Upgrade now and lead with confidence, clarity, and calm—every single week.

Already a paying subscriber? Sign In.

A subscription gets you:

• • Plug-and-play talk tracks - Get word-for-word scripts for handling tough conversations, performance reviews, and escalation calls—so you never freeze or fumble.
• • Confidence boosters before key moments - Quick-read mindset resets and one-liners to ground you before team meetings, 1:1s, or presentations.
• • Proven leadership templates - Use battle-tested coaching plans, escalation frameworks, and team comms templates that save you hours and build trust fast.
• • Messaging that lands - Learn how to say what you mean with clarity and confidence—whether you’re giving tough feedback or rallying a demotivated team.
• • Creative engagement ideas - Inject energy into your team with easy-to-steal ideas for engagement, recognition, and alignment—even when morale is low.