In partnership with
AI made PMs faster. Multiplayer mode is still broken.
A PM can summarize research, draft a PRD, and mock up a prototype before lunch. The hard part starts when the team has to decide what actually gets built.
Jira Product Discovery gives product teams one place to capture insights, prioritize ideas with consistent frameworks, and build living roadmaps stakeholders can rally around.
And because it’s connected to Jira, the context behind every decision stays with the work—so developers and their agents know not just what to build, but why.
AI helps PMs move faster. Jira Product Discovery helps the whole team build with confidence.
Covering today
Why underperformance rarely fixes itself
Why good managers delay difficult conversations
How to separate facts from assumptions
Seven steps for addressing performance fairly
How to balance support with accountability
When improvement is no longer the likely outcome
The Performance Conversation You’re Avoiding
Most managers don’t ignore underperformance because they don’t care.
They ignore it because they do.
They don’t want to knock someone’s confidence.
They know the person is dealing with challenges outside work.
They’re worried about damaging the relationship.
So they wait.
Stay on top of the economic trends affecting your business — in plain English, every other Friday.
Subscribe free → fridayfinancedc.com.
They give another chance without saying that another chance is being given. They quietly compensate for the gap. They redistribute work, lower expectations or hope the person eventually works it out.
But underperformance rarely improves through silence.
The employee remains unaware of the seriousness of the problem.
Their colleagues become frustrated.
The manager becomes resentful.
And a conversation that could have been constructive becomes increasingly difficult.
Addressing underperformance early isn’t unkind.
Leaving someone unaware that they’re falling short is.
The problem Alex hoped would disappear
Alex managed an experienced team of seven.
One member of the team had started missing deadlines. The quality of their work had become inconsistent and colleagues were regularly stepping in to finish tasks.
Alex noticed it.
But he also knew the employee was going through a difficult period personally.
So he waited.
He offered encouragement, moved a few deadlines and took some of the work himself. He believed he was being supportive.
Three months later, nothing had improved.
When Alex finally raised the issue, the employee was shocked.
They had interpreted his support as evidence that everything was broadly fine.
Alex thought he had been giving them time.
The employee thought they had been meeting expectations.
That gap existed because the manager had never clearly named it.
1. Name the gap
Underperformance is not a personality judgement.
It’s a gap between what is expected and what is currently happening.
Before speaking to someone, get specific:
What result or behaviour is expected?
What have you observed instead?
What impact is this having?
What evidence supports your view?
Avoid vague statements such as:
“You need to be more proactive.”
Explain what proactive would look like:
“I expected you to flag the delivery risk before Friday’s deadline. I only became aware after the customer escalated it on Monday.”
The clearer the gap, the easier it becomes to discuss fairly.
2. Diagnose the cause
Not every performance problem has the same cause.
Someone may be struggling because they:
Don’t understand what is expected
Haven’t been properly trained
Lack the time, tools or authority required
Are overwhelmed by competing priorities
Have lost confidence
Are choosing not to meet the standard
Those situations require different responses.
Start with curiosity:
“I’ve noticed the last three reports were submitted after the deadline. Talk me through what’s getting in the way.”
Listen before deciding what the problem is.
Curiosity helps you diagnose the gap.
It shouldn’t prevent you from acknowledging that the gap exists.
Build a Holiday Creator Affiliate Program in 90 Days
Creators lock in holiday content calendars 90 days out, before brands figure out commissions. Waiting too long to launch an affiliate program means less runway to build demand and a missed shot at the best partnerships.
The 90-Day Holiday Sprint covers commissions, recruiting, and scaling a program at Day 30, 60, and 90.
3. Agree the recovery plan
A performance conversation should create clarity about what happens next.
Agree:
What needs to change
Which actions the employee will take
What support you will provide
How improvement will be measured
When progress will be reviewed
“Do better” isn’t a plan.
“Submit the weekly report by 3pm every Friday for the next four weeks” is.
Finish by asking:
“Can you explain what we’ve agreed in your own words?”
That question reveals whether the expectation is genuinely clear.
4. Provide the right support
Accountability without support can become abandonment.
Support without accountability can become avoidance.
The rest of this edition is article is exclusively to House of Leadership members.
Unlock the complete article, weekly premium leadership insights, practical frameworks, and monthly 1:1 coaching calls to accelerate your growth. Upgrade to continue reading →
Become a member